The Publishing Times
All the News That’s Fit to Publish
book-marketing · Guides
Why Book Reviews Still Matter in a Crowded Market
With huge numbers of new books published every year, reviews remain one of the strongest signals readers use to decide. Here is how reviews work for discovery and how authors can earn them ethically.
Do book reviews still matter? Yes. The number of books released each year keeps growing, especially through self-publishing, and readers need ways to sort them. Reviews are one of the most trusted signals available. A book with no reviews asks readers to take a risk. A book with many thoughtful reviews feels safer.
What reviews do
- Social proof. Shoppers look at the number of ratings and the average before reading a description.
- Conversion. Detailed reviews answer questions the blurb does not, such as pacing, heat level or content warnings, which helps the right readers buy.
- Eligibility. Some promotional newsletters set minimum review counts or ratings for books they feature.
- Advertising. Ads perform better when the product page has credible reviews.
- Feedback. Patterns in reviews tell authors what readers love and what frustrates them.
Kinds of reviews
Customer reviews on retail sites and Goodreads reflect the reader's experience. Editorial reviews from trade publications or professional review services provide quotes for covers and product pages, and can reach librarians and booksellers. Media and blogger reviews target specific communities. Each type fulfills a distinct role.
Earning reviews ethically
Retailers have strict rules. Paying for reviews, trading reviews with other authors, or offering incentives in exchange for positive ratings can get reviews removed and accounts penalized. Ethical methods include:
- Advance reader copies. Give early copies to readers who agree to consider an honest review, through author lists or services such as NetGalley and BookFunnel.
- A request in the back matter. A short, polite note at the end of the book, where satisfied readers are, works well.
- The author's newsletter. Subscribers are often the most invested readers and likely to provide feedback.
- Professional review services. Some offer paid editorial reviews, which are disclosed as such and are different from paid customer reviews.
For more, see the guide to getting Amazon reviews without breaking the rules.
Handling negative reviews
Authors are advised not to respond publicly to criticism of the book. A mix of ratings looks authentic, and critical reviews help readers who would not enjoy the book avoid it, which protects the average over time.
The long view
Reviews accumulate. A book that earns a steady trickle over years builds lasting credibility. For authors, the best review strategy is still writing a book readers want to talk about, then making it easy for them to do so.