The Publishing Times

All the News That’s Fit to Publish

publishing-news · Guides

Amazon Ebook Antitrust Case: Judge Recommends a 30 Million-Buyer Class

A magistrate judge has recommended certifying a class of more than 30 million Amazon ebook buyers. A less-redacted version of his report was refiled in early October, and Amazon has objected.

Will millions of Amazon ebook buyers be able to sue Amazon as a single group? A federal magistrate judge in New York has recommended that they should. In In re Amazon.com, Inc. eBook Antitrust Litigation (No. 1:21-cv-00351, S.D.N.Y.), Magistrate Judge Gabriel W. Gorenstein recommended granting the plaintiffs' motion for class certification. The plaintiffs' law firm, Hagens Berman, says the proposed class covers more than 30 million consumers.

The recommendation does not settle the matter. The case is assigned to U.S. District Judge Gregory H. Woods, who will decide whether to adopt it.

What the docket shows

The court docket shows the case was filed on January 14, 2021, assigned to Judge Woods and referred to Judge Gorenstein, with its most recent entry, a report and recommendation filing, dated October 1, 2026. Hagens Berman announced the recommendation on October 2, referring to an "Oct. 1, 2026, report and recommendation filing."

Who would be in the class

According to Hagens Berman, the class would include people who bought at least one trade ebook published by the Big Five (Hachette, HarperCollins, Macmillan, Penguin Random House, and Simon & Schuster) through Amazon.com under the agency model, on or after January 14, 2017, through the date of class certification, and who paid between $4.00 and $49.99. The case was filed on January 14, 2021, so the class period reaches back four years before filing, the limitations period for federal antitrust damages claims.

The firm says Judge Gorenstein's report also recommends appointing Hagens Berman and Sperling & Slater as co-lead class counsel.

What the plaintiffs allege

The lawsuit alleges that Amazon maintains anticompetitive agreements with the five largest ebook publishers that prevent their ebooks from being sold at lower prices on other retail platforms, and that Amazon used those agreements to preserve its dominance in ebooks. Hagens Berman says the suit claims the agreements allow Amazon to charge a commission on ebook sales "that is at least 30% and higher than it would earn in a competitive market." These remain allegations; no court has ruled on whether they are true.

What the report describes

Hagens Berman quotes the 35-page report's discussion of the plaintiffs' expert evidence:

  • Damages model. Plaintiffs' expert Dr. Jamie McClave constructed a model from 658 million Amazon ebook transactions covering nearly a decade. The report says she "determined that Amazon customers paid over $740 million more (in aggregate) for trade eBooks published by the Big Five than they would have in a competitive market." That figure is the plaintiffs' expert estimate, not a finding of liability.
  • Market share. Another plaintiffs' expert, Wickelgren, places Amazon's share "consistently within the range of 69-74%" throughout the class period, according to the report.
  • Contract changes. The report describes Amazon replacing "Hybrid Seller of Record" contracts with "Tiered Seller of Record" contracts, after which, it says, "Amazon virtually stopped price-matching."

On the central legal question for certification, the firm quotes Judge Gorenstein: "In the end, because the antitrust damages model constructed by McClave is consistent with plaintiffs' theory of antitrust impact, plaintiffs have shown that common issues predominate in establishing antitrust damages."

"We are pleased with Judge Gorenstein's thorough read of this case," said Steve Berman, managing partner at Hagens Berman.

What happens next

Judge Woods will review the report and decide whether to certify the class. If he does, the case will proceed on behalf of the entire class rather than individual buyers.

Why it matters for authors

The case was brought by ebook buyers, not authors, and it concerns Big Five agency-model ebooks, not self-published titles. Even so, the evidence now on the public record bears on how Amazon priced, and matched prices on, the bestselling trade ebooks that indie books compete against. The report's account of Amazon moving to new contract terms and "virtually" stopping price-matching is the kind of detail that publishers and authors follow closely, because it affects how ebook prices are set across stores. A certified class would also raise the stakes of the case for Amazon.

Sources