The Publishing Times

All the News That’s Fit to Publish

publishing-news · Guides

Writer Beware Follows One Editor Scam to a $900 Fee

Writer Beware followed one AI editor scam from a fake Soho Press pitch through a misspelled agent name to a $900 rewrite fee the writer did not pay.

An impersonation scam that uses generative AI to pose as real editors has become the single most-reported fraud reaching Writer Beware, which says it now gets two or three reports a day and hundreds in all. The 13 November 2026 post follows one writer's emails from the first pitch to the fee, and says the writer did not pay.

What the opening email pretends to be

Writer Beware calls it the Editor Scam. The message claims to come from an editor at a real house, with praise and details that make the sender look familiar with the book. The editor and the publisher check out, and links in the message may be real as well. The address does not. A genuine note, the post says, would come from a company domain, not from Gmail or AOL, though the fake address may tuck the publisher's name into the local part. The scammer plays the editor, the agent, and the person brought in to "fix" the manuscript.

In the case written up here, the name on the first email was Nick Whitney, presented as a senior editor. The house name in the message was wrong. "Soho Press, not Sohopress," the post says, and other than memoirs Soho does not publish nonfiction, let alone the academic work this writer had produced. The post says it stripped the personal detail, and left in phrases it treats as an automatic tell.

Those lines, as Writer Beware lists them, include "I recently came across your book," usually near the start, and "What particularly caught my attention," which often introduces the personal bit. A third is "I also find X especially interesting." The sign-off "Warm regards" is another. The post also tells readers to watch for particularly, especially, and intriguing or intrigued. The Impersonation List, it says, has more than doubled, because the scammers burn through staff rosters and drop a name after a few weeks.

The agent with an extra letter

The writer answered on 30 October. The reply the same day asked for the manuscript, and the writer sent it on 3 November. Within hours came more praise and a referral to an agent. The surname had an extra letter. The post says it is not clear why, and guesses that a Gmail address for the real spelling may already have been taken. On 4 November the writer wrote to that address and sent the manuscript a second time. The answer came that afternoon and claimed the whole manuscript had been read in those few hours.

In most versions, the post says, the supposed agent next points the writer to a third party described as an "experienced editorial professional." This time the fake agent offered to do the editing herself, through a company called Booklume, whose address was in the signature. The site, the post says, is a single page: no staff biographies or resumes, no client list, a portfolio of just four books, two of them with dead Amazon links, and no mention of the agent under either spelling. The writer went on anyway. An editing proposal followed, heavy with reassurance about the care the work would get. The post says these scams do not like to leave a target time to think. When a day passed with no answer, another note arrived. "I would be pleased to hear your thoughts on the proposed scope of work and the $900 fee for the complete manuscript rewrite," she wrote on 6 November, the post says. "I look forward to hearing from you."

Why the wire transfer ended it

On 7 November the writer agreed and asked how to pay. The choices were a wire transfer, PayPal, or a payment app, and the writer chose the wire. Writer Beware says a wire is almost impossible to reverse, unlike a card payment and, to a lesser extent, PayPal, and that writers should not pay publishing expenses that way. In this case the wire is what stopped the loss. The instructions told the writer to send the money to a third party they had never heard of, with no apparent tie to the fake agent or to Booklume. That was the point, the post says, at which the writer looked the story up and wrote to the real agent, who confirmed it was a scam.

The writer did not lose money and did not hand over banking details. What they lost, the post says, was nearly two weeks of replies, and the hope the exchange had been building. The post says it is often impossible to say where a scam starts. Where the author has been able to trace this wave, including marketing pitches, book clubs, reading groups and impersonations from the last couple of years, they most often lead to Nigeria, and this one did too. One sign was the name on the payment instructions. A firmer one was the domain record for Booklume: the registrant, unusually, did not turn on domain privacy.

The last part of the post is less about this exchange than about spotting the writing. Along with the solicitation phrases and "warm regards," it flags the opener "thoughtful response" or "thoughtful message." That line, the post says, appears in so many replies that the repetition can hint you are not dealing with a real person. It also showcases the obsequiousness that is such a feature of generative AI writing.