The Publishing Times
All the News That’s Fit to Publish
publishing-news · Guides
German Publishers Open Frankfurt With an Appeal for AI Training Transparency
As Frankfurter Buchmesse opens, the Börsenverein published the Frankfurt Appeal, backed by 120 publishers, asking EU and German lawmakers to force AI firms to disclose training data.

What do Germany's publishers want from lawmakers as the world's biggest book fair opens? Proof of what AI companies trained on. On October 6, 2026, the Börsenverein des Deutschen Buchhandels, the German Publishers and Booksellers Association, released the "Frankfurt Appeal," addressed to the European Commission, the European Parliament, and the German federal government. The association said 120 publishers had already signed it.
The appeal was issued at the start of Frankfurter Buchmesse, which runs October 7 to 11, 2026, with Czechia as Guest of Honour.
"Two-fold theft"
The Börsenverein introduced the appeal with a warning from its chairman, Sebastian Guggolz. "If policymakers fail to act now, AI will not only continue to rob millions of copyright-protected works from us, but will also, in the long term, rob us of our ability to think," he said. The association's press release summarized the point in its headline as a "two-fold theft by AI: first our books, then our thoughts."
Guggolz said that where AI is concerned, non-European corporations are setting the terms. "AI companies use copyright-protected works without consent or remuneration to train their systems," he said. "Since there are no clear legal obligations to disclose training data, content owners are forced to conduct time-consuming searches for evidence themselves and enforce their claims through costly legal proceedings."
What the appeal asks for
The appeal, published in German on the Börsenverein's website, states that AI companies train their models on copyright-protected works without the consent of publishers and authors, and that they largely face no sanctions even when they disregard rights holders' explicit reservations against such use. In the absence of clear legal duties, it says, AI companies do not disclose which works they used, even though doing so is technically possible.
The signatories ask lawmakers to guarantee three things:
- Work-level transparency. Disclosure duties for AI companies must cover the specific training data for each work. The appeal says the general guidelines that currently apply to AI providers fall clearly short of what the EU AI Act requires, and it notes that one of the Act's stated purposes is to help rights holders enforce their rights.
- A licensing market with fair revenue models. The appeal says the text-and-data-mining rule has so far allowed AI providers to help themselves de facto without paying, and that opt-out reservations are frequently ignored.
- Enforceable copyright. Existing European copyright law must be upheld and made enforceable. "Rights whose violation has no consequences are worthless," the appeal says (PT's translation from the German).
The appeal contends that for the great majority of European publishers, suing the world's most powerful AI companies is not a practical option, so infringements go unpunished and the revenue remains with the AI firms at the expense of publishers, authors, illustrators, and translators.
Who has signed
The public list of signatories includes Penguin Random House Verlagsgruppe, Holtzbrinck Buchverlage, Bonnier Media Deutschland, Hanser, Suhrkamp, Diogenes, dtv, Bastei Lübbe, Rowohlt, S. Fischer, and Verlag C.H.Beck, along with many smaller houses. The Federation of European Publishers and the International Publishers Association also appear on the list. The page invites additional publishers to sign, and it asks authors, translators, and illustrators who support the appeal to encourage their own publishers to join.
Reading literacy
The Börsenverein coupled the AI appeal with a warning about reading. Citing the latest PISA study, it said one-third of 15-year-olds lack adequate reading skills. It also reported that the number of young people aged 10 to 15 who bought books fell 30.6 percent in 2025 compared with the previous year. "Those who can no longer read for comprehension are not able to verify an AI response at all," Guggolz said.
Guggolz called for daily reading sessions in schools, as proposed by the "Leseband" initiative, and for media literacy to be made a compulsory subject.
At the fair
The Börsenverein scheduled two related panels on the Dialogue Stage in Foyer Hall 4.0: one on gaps in AI regulation on Thursday, October 8, at 11:30, with speakers including Member of the European Parliament Nela Riehl and Rainer Dresen of Penguin Random House Verlagsgruppe, and one on the education crisis on Friday, October 9, at 14:00.
Why it matters for authors
The appeal is directed at European and German lawmakers, but its central demand, a legal duty for AI companies to disclose which specific works they trained on, could matter to any author whose books are published or sold in Europe. At present, as the appeal describes it, rights holders must search for evidence on their own before they can even raise a claim. Work-by-work disclosure would make it far easier to determine whether a book was used and to negotiate or enforce a license. The appeal also shows how much of German trade publishing, from the largest groups to small independents, now stands behind the same demand.
Sources
- Börsenverein des Deutschen Buchhandels: Start of Frankfurter Buchmesse: "Two-fold theft by AI: first our books, then our thoughts" (October 6, 2026)
- Börsenverein des Deutschen Buchhandels: Frankfurter Appell (appeal text and signatories, in German)
- Frankfurter Buchmesse: Frankfurter Buchmesse 2026 (dates and Guest of Honour)